Site Navigation
HomeAbout
Services
Testimonials
Contact
Info
FAQ
Smitty's Overtime Inn
"Cold Beer and Good Eats"
About Us
Smitty's Overtime Inn in Tomah, WI, is the premier dining destination for Monroe County and surrounding areas. Our menu features mouthwatering fish fry, tender prime rib, juicy ribs, crispy chicken, fresh seafood, and handcrafted burgers—all made to satisfy your cravings. Don't forget to try our homemade pizza, served fresh until the bar closes! Whether you're stopping in for a hearty meal or a late-night bite, Smitty’s Overtime Inn is your top choice. Call us at 608-372-5499 to place an order or reserve your table today!
Areas Served
Monroe County, WI | Tomah, WI
Our Professional Associations
- Wisconsin Tavern League
- Wisconsin State Cranberry Growers Association
What We Offer
Our Services include:
- Welcome to Smitty’s Overtime Inn, where great food, bold flavors, and good times come together! Dive into our signature Big Red Bloody Mary, then stick around for mouthwatering favorites like juicy burgers, crispy chicken and ribs, our famous Friday Fish Fry, and homemade pizzas hot from the oven. Craving something special? Don’t miss our tender prime rib and fresh seafood selections. Pair your meal with a drink from our rotating seasonal taps, featuring local brews like Spotted Cow, Hop and Barrel, and Crooked Grin, or sip on a glass of Cabernet, Moscato, or Chardonnay. We also serve 1919 Root Beer and a variety of Carbliss and Crook & Marker seltzers. Whether you're here for the food, the drinks, or the atmosphere — Smitty’s is your go-to spot for flavor and fun!
Our Brands include:
- What's on Tap? (Check out our Season Taps)
- 1919 Rootbeer
- Blue Moon
- Bud Light
- Cabernet
- Carbliss Seltzers
- Chardonnay
- Contented Cow
- Crook & Marker Seltzer
- Crooked Grin
- Hop and Barrel Brewery
- Merlot
- Minnesconsin
- Moscato
- Riesling
- Roscato
- Snappy IPA
- Spotted Cow
- White Zinfandel
- Wine
- Wisconsin Capital
- Woodys Easy Ale
Our Products include:
- Big Red Bloody Mary
- Burgers
- Chicken and Rib
- Fish Fry
- Homemade Pizza
- Prime Rib
- Seafood
Testimonials
On 1/28/2026
Jess Hutzler
had this to say:
I have been meeting my friends from the lacrosse there for a year or so about once a we keep coming back. by the way Nancy is an awesome waitresses.
On 1/25/2026
Jenny Bannink
had this to say:
Amazing little gem with delicious food and exceptionally friendly service! We will definitely be back again on our next trip through the area! 😋🍻🩷
On 12/21/2025
Jake E
had this to say:
Great burgers and for a great price!
On 11/14/2025
Joyce Gaulke
had this to say:
Our waitress was great in helping us make decisions on what to order.
On 10/25/2025
Jess Hutzler
had this to say:
I have been meeting my friends from the lacrosse there for a year or so about once a we keep coming back. by the way Nancy is an awesome waitresses.
Contact Us
Smitty's Overtime Inn
8293 Hwy 173 Tomah, WI 54660
Phone: (608) 372-5499
Email: smittys2016
Located on Hwy 173. Wheel Chair Accessible
Where To Find Us
Follow us on GoogleFollow us on Facebook
Follow us on Yelp
Payment Types Accepted
MasterCard, Visa, Debit Cards
Our Hours
Holiday Hours May Vary. Please Call For Details.
Tuesday: 10:30 AM - 12:00 AM Kitchen Hours: 11:00AM - 9:00PM
Wednesday: 10:30 AM - 12:00 AM Kitchen Hours: 11:00AM - 9:00PM
Thursday: 10:30 AM - 12:00 AM Kitchen Hours: 11:00AM - 9:00PM
Friday: 10:30 AM - 2:00 AM Kitchen Hours: 11:00AM - 9:00PM
Saturday: 10:30 AM - 2:00 AM Kitchen Hours: 11:00AM - 9:00PM
Sunday: 10:30 AM - 11:00 PM Kitchen Hours: 11:00AM - 8:00PM
Info
Valentine's Dinner MenuSpecials Jan 27-30th
Specials Feb 2-6th
Specials Feb 10-13th
Specials Feb 17-20th
Specials Feb 24-27th
Friday Fish Fry
Chicken Wings/ Drummies
Menu
FAQ
Legal
Terms of UsePrivacy Policy